Holes, written by louis sachar, was awarded the newbery medal in 1999. While some people prefer to read the book first and others want to see the movie before reading the book, there is value in comparing books and movies. Stanley and zero head back to camp to see what will happen to them. Holes by louis sacher is the splendid story of an unlucky boy called. Students will be asked to make find relevant, deep comparisons and differences. Comparing the movie sherlock holmes and the book can be difficult. Since she doesnt affect the plot, her existence wasnt vital in the film. Similarities between the holes book and the holes movie. For a no prep way to have students compare and contrast a book with its movie, check out my book vs. Differences between holes book and film holes wiki fandom. In the book there is a character by the name of sarah miller, she is the wife of elya. Differences between the holes book and the holes movie. Do not delve in if you want the film to be a surprise.
Holes book vs movie summary and comparison madeline matthews run zero, run. Similarities between the holes book and the holes movie answers. After we were done, we noticed that the book and the movie were not the same. I had to write a compare and contrast essay and this is like half of it. While matilda and lavender are friends in the novel, matilda has no direct interaction with bruce bogtrotter and amanda thripp. Sherlock holmes comparing the movie and the book hubpages. In the movie, hes trying to cure foot odor all along. First, jot down ideas about how the two versions of the story are similar. The book obviously had more details that could help illustrate the settings in your mind, but a movie brought it to the next power.
I would like to point out a few of the similarities and differences which i will be going into more details in the next few paragraphs. I need some examples of differences between the book and the movie. Stanley arrives at camp green lake and he meets mr sir, a man who is trying to use sunflower seeds to stop smoking. What are the similarities and differences between the book. In this edition of book to screen, perri breaks down room the movie and sees how it compares to emma donoghues novel of the same name. Hales wife is mentioned in the movie and not in the playwright or book. The maze runner book to film differences the maze runner. The difference between holes the book and holes the. Holes by louis sacher is the splendid story of an unlucky boy called stanley. The similarities from the the book holes and the movie holes. The source of his nickname is never mentioned, nor is his. There exists a number of things that could contradict the statements above, questioning why there even needs to be any comparing of the two. Holes, penned by louis sachar, relates the story of stanley yelnats who has been accused and then awarded jail time for taking a pair of sneakers.
Movie vs book comparisons and similarities collider. Get an answer for what are some of the differences and similarities between the movie and the book beloved. The student will compare and contrast holes the book to holes the movie free rubric builder and assessment tools. Zero first throws up and then rolls a little part down the mountain until stanley caught him in the book he just stood up by himself and didnt fall also the bugs came after they were up the mountain. There are many similarities between the novel hoot by carl hiaasen and the movie by the same name. Sent away to a reformatory, camp green lake, yelnats finds that the odd practice of making the kids dig holes is not a kind of penalty devised by the sadistic warden however actually a look for a. Stanley was over weight in the book and in the movie stanley was not over weight. There are several differences between the book and its movie adaptation. Unlike many book adaptations, the maze runner, while constantly nodding at its source material, is very different from the book it is based on.
But if you really wanna find out the similarities and differences between the book and the movie, then you have to read and watch them. Did the setting in the movie look like you had imagined it. The differences between the book holes and the movie holes. Charlie and the chocolate factory in 2005, and willy wonka and the chocolate factory in 1971. Stanley was overweight, which contributed to many altercations with the school bully derrick dunne. Similarities between the book and movie animal farm 1835. What are the differences and similarities between stanley and zero. The following are noted differences between the maze runner book and the maze runner film. This culminating activity asks students to compare and contrast the book holes and its movie adaptation.
Movie and book comparison notes holes similarities differences. Good ones for this are the harry potter series, holes, the chronicles of narnia series, and where. The movie follows the life of a boy, stanley, who due to a family curse, ends up in a juvenile detention center out in the middle of nowhere after being falsely. The major difference between the book and the movie is that there is minimal character development in the movie, and the viewer is unable to become more familiar with the characters. The similarities between the book holes and the movie holes are the camp stanley goes to, the way he is treated at the camp, and the treasure stanley. Igor barkov plays a very minor role in the mole in the movie. Use this worksheet to compare and contrast the book and the movie. Holes reflection there are a number of differences between the book and the movie. As this movie went from scene to scenefollowing the book almost.
This free packet includes 4 graphic organizers to use when comparing and contrasting details from a book and the movie. In the film, it is implied that there is a friendship between matilda, lavender, hortensia, bruce bogtrotter and amanda thripp. Hole summary points back to camp green lake stanley and zeros friendship blossoms. My class noticed these cutoff parts in english class and compared the book to the movie. One of the most notable changes i noticed was that sherlock is not nearly as blunt, nor violent in the book. Movie post and i have almost no differences to speak of. Differences between the book and the movie features charting how the hate u give book differs from the movie changes to characters, a different ending and more. Something else that occurs in the book is an incident between stanley and zigzag. Whats the difference between holes the book and holes the movie.
It includes questions, charts, a scaffolded compare and contrast essay template, and more. For example, stanleys dad is developing a way to recycle sneakers in the book, and accidentally comes across a treatment for foot odor. The source of his nickname is never mentioned, nor is his real name. Charlie and the chocolate factory book versus charlie and the chocolate factory film comparison chart. According to, other differences between the movie and the book extend to scenes in the movie that are much shallower in detail than in the book. One day, zigzag fights with stanley, but zero saves stanley by strangling zigzag, and mr pendanski shoots a bullet in the air to stop them. In both the book and the movie jonas receives the memory of snow and a sled ride first.
What are the similarities between the holes book and the. The people that are in charge of the boys in the detention camp are not the nicest of people and they are very strict with the boys. It is almost easier to explain what is different because the movie does follow the book very closely. In the book, thomas immediately remembers his name upon arriving in the glade. Outsiders book and movie comparison free essay example. A few similarities between the movie and book are that the movie still has the complete greaser gang pony, johnny, soda, darry, dally, twobit and steve. What differences are there between holes the book and holes the movie by louis sachar. I have read the book holes and also watched the movie, i realize that the movie and the book have more similarities than differences. Then stanley meets mr pendanski one of the counsellors at camp green lake.
To ease my conscience and give my students the opportunity to both read the book and watch the movie, i created this fun project to test their comparing and contrasting skills. Best of all, it can be used over and over again with any book that has a movie companion. Great comparison, i didnt even know there was a movie and i only read holes late last year, ill try and find a copy here. The third major similarity i noticed between the book and movie version of holes was at the end of the book when stanley and zero found the buried treasure. What are some of the differences and similarities between. The book was adapted into two major motion pictures. Similarities and differences in book and movie holes, written by louis sachar, was awarded the newbery medal in 1999. This is an evident similarity between the book and movie. In the film, matilda breaks into the trunchbulls home twice. Hector zero reunited with his mother after many years they were separated. On the mountain, stanley and zero had to dig for water in the book and in the movie they did not dig for.
Get an answer for what are the differences and similarities between stanley and zero in. The main character, stanley yelnats, had a difficult time with life in general. Holes was adapted by walt disney pictures as a feature film of the same name released in 2003. For example, there are many similarities, but also some distinct differences. What differences are there between holes the book and. A classic childrens book and shia labeouf before he wentjoaquin phoenix. Three of the major similarities between the book and movie version of the outsiders were the death of bob, johnny, and dally. In the movie abigail visits john proctor while he is in jail but.
Watching a movie after reading the book is a wonderful way to encourage students to think critically about how each medium presented roughly the same information. The differences between the book and the film stanley was overweight in the book. Stanley yelnets was acused of stealing the shoes that was going towards charity. There are many spoilers in the insurgent book to movie comparison.
Get an answer for what are more information the differences and similarities between stanley and zero in louis sachars holes. There were not a lot of holes in the book and a lot of holes in the movie. Trout is called trout because his feet smell like fish. He shows stanley his tent, tent d, and he meets armpit, xray, zigzag. Compare and contrast holes book and movie free essays. Tuck everlasting movie and book from the story of harry potter to the trilogy of lord of the rings, there are many books which have been produced and aired to big screens. The majority of the book alternates between the present day story of stanley yelnats, the story of elya yelnats in latvia.
Holes is a 1998 young adult novel written by louis sachar and first published by farrar, straus. In louis sachars novel holes, why does zero like digging holes. There are a few other minor differences, but theyre so minor that it feels sort of petty to bring them up. Some differences between the play book and the movie are. In 2003 it was adapted into a very entertaining movie. In the film, he doesnt remember it until later that night after his arrival when he banged his head in a fight with gally in the book, the creators business is written as w. Images of book movie props such as shovels, hats, snakes, etc. In the movie the writers neglect to mention her existence. Those who read and watched the book and the movie of a certain story are very interested of comparing the context of the two. One day, zigzag fights with stanley, but zero saves stanley by strangling zigzag, and mr pendanski shoots a bullet in the. The book instructions the movie holes is based on the book of the same title by louis sachar. The movie holes 2003 was directed by andrew davis who used the writer of holes, louis sacher as a consultant on the set during production movie hole interview october 6, 2003. If you know a difference, dont comment, add it above. They also make the boys dig a big hole everyday they are at the detention camp in both versions of the story.
After students have finished reading the book holes, arrange for a classroom screening. They reach camp green lake and hide out in the hole where stanley found the lipstick tube and start digging. The book stands as a very old book, standards for a story could have changed since the time it was published and required changes to a movie. Stanley taught he was at camp green lake of his grandpas. This is a project designed for students to complete after reading the book holes and watching the film holes.
743 936 741 375 104 689 1031 1183 1491 471 1465 947 163 542 816 1183 1461 1262 874 543 1305 849 314 158 1516 1464 66 1363 1115 1349 954 1343 90 1064 1039 975 611 366 874 334 172 1397 720 680 250 1109 374 1015